I have been offered this deal...I would send Edge and Antonio Gates and in return I would get Warrick Dunn and Tony G.....my other Rbs are Kevin Jones, Duece McCallister and Deangelo Williams....

What do you think?

No. As bad as Edge has been, he's still close to Dunn. There is a big gap between Gates and Gonzo though. So you're losing the better TE and not necessarily getting an every week starter at RB, since you have KJ and Deuce.

I agree with Bullies. Gates is the best player in this deal. Don't do it.

Thanks.....that pretty much the way i was leaning but wanted to get your opinions...