We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 Util. (WR/RB/TE), 1 ST/D, 1 PK

1 Pt. Rec., 1 pt. 10 yds Rush/Rec., 6 pts. TD

I was offered:
JP Losman, Travis Henry, and Kellen Winslow
FOR
Vince Young, Reggie Bush

My other players:
RB - Deuce McCallister, Maurice Jones-Drew, Deshaun Foster
WR - Lee Evans, Jerricho Cotchery, DJ Hackett
TE - Alge Crumpler

What do you think???

Assuming you have Losman, Henry, and Winslow - not a chance.

You downgrade here at both QB and RB while adding Winslow. But you have Crumpler. I see no advantage to making a trade like this.

I'd be getting Losman, Henry, and Winslow...and giving Bush and Young.

It's a close trade but I wouldn't do it. I disagree with skip here (if I'm understanding it correctly)... I see Young as a higher pick/potential then Losman and I have Bush ranked slightly higher then Henry so I see no reason to downgrade at both positions. Adding Winslow is nice and he may be slightly better then Crumpler but not by much. I'd stick with what you have unless you think that Young is doomed to be injured and Henry's numbers will be significantly greater then what Bush puts up which I don't.

I would much, much rather have Young and Bush. Not even close.

I'd laugh and hit the "reject trade" button as fast as possible.

Yeah, I rejected it. He had a 2nd and 4th round pick packaged with the players for later picks of mine. But, with 16 teams and 9 players protected by each...the picks are for "discards".

The owner who made the trade offered Losman and Winlsow for Bush and Young two days ago and I laughed. But, this is his forte'....he makes trades based upon "potential" rather than past performance and the team they are on. We usually juust say "Insane $%O)^" is at it again. Not many owners trade with him due to the fact that he overvalues his players and doesn't have a sense of FFL reality.

quote:

Originally posted by Ed Hoyle:
.....doesn't have a sense of FFL reality.

That line made me chuckle


And yeah, horrible trade.

quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Burns:
(if I'm understanding it correctly)

No, we basically have the same assessment and I don't think this is a close offer at all - esp with Crumpler on the roster.

I had brought up the trade for earlier picks and I'd give McCallister. Losman/Evans tandom could be good, but again, I'd need earlier draft picks to consider it.

Regardless, I declined and won't give up both Young and Bush. Maybe Young, but Bush is not going anywhere.

Thanks for the advice guys.