Hey all. Ok, my draft is in a couple weeks. We keep 1 player. My only real choices are Peyton Manning or Larry Fitzgerald. Manning out scored Fitzy by over 90 points last year. However, I am almost 100% sure that I could keep Fitzy and get Warner with my first pick. If I waited till second rd he would most certainly be gone. If I keep Peyton I would end up taking Slaton/Gore/LT...with my first pick. Which is certainly not a bad thing. I am very much up in the air over this. Please help. Thanx!!! (scoring is typical, not a PPR league)

I keep Fitz and not even think about it. The top tier WRs are far better than the next tier. You can not say the same thing about QBs.

I keep Fitz and still take Slaton, Gore, or LT with my 1st pick.

Really??? Man, it is so hard to drop Manning. I won the whole thing last year and my RBs were horrible. Having a top QB really made the deference. Obviously having Fitzy did not hurt either. 22 out of the top 25 total point getters were QBs last year. Granted Manning was number 5 or 6...This is a huge decision. This could literally effect my whole season. More imput would be appreciated.

quote:

Originally posted by The Waffle:
either. 22 out of the top 25 total point getters were QBs last year.

This is exactly why you DON'T keep Manning. If QBs are able to score that much in your league that 22 of them were in the top 25 overall, then unless there is a huge disparity between the top 3-5 QBs and the rest of the pack, it simply isn't worth it.

quote:

Originally posted by gianmarco:

quote:

Originally posted by The Waffle:
either. 22 out of the top 25 total point getters were QBs last year.

This is exactly why you DON'T keep Manning. If QBs are able to score that much in your league that 22 of them were in the top 25 overall, then unless there is a huge disparity between the top 3-5 QBs and the rest of the pack, it simply isn't worth it.

Exactly right.

Fitz and it isn't even close.

Alright!!! I will keep my fingers crossed for Warner. Thanks for the help!!!