im in a 6 player keeper league w/ a 3 yr contract on each player. there are eight teams ive offered the following trade dillion,mccallister and pittman for manning these are my other keepers
1.james
2. thomas
3 taylor
4 t davis
5 t jones or c chambers

just to clear things up a little im trading for manning and getting rid of 3 running backs

Are QBs getting 6 pts for a passing TD?

Even if they are your RBs will be done by week 3..all of which have BIG injury issues...

Ummmmm No way in hell .....

At first I was going to ask if you are nuts or something but then I realized that since you can only keep 6, you might as well try for Manning. However, I would pick a different 3 RBs. I would try to offer either Dillon, Taylor and Pittman or McAllister, Taylor and Pittman to see if he will bite. You are still offering him more talent than he is giving up but you leave yourself in a much better position. Also, I would probably drop T Davis and keep both Chambers and T Jones instead. If he won't bite on the trade as mentioned above, don't give up what you are offering. You would be much better served to keep James, Thomas, Dillon, McAllister, Pittman and Chambers. With so many RBs, someone should be willing to deal with you later in the year, even in an 8 team league.

try ti keep dillon and offer any other back

if he doesnt bite then just hold steady and hog the RBs

James
Thomas
Dillon
McAllister
Pittman
and yes Taylor... with so much talent y not take a chance on him being healthy a full your? then trade some away mid season as rbs do go down or taylor proves himself or james or pittman.. people will b coming to u left and right and u can snag some WRs then

Listen to Iguana

Under NO circumstances should you make the deal you originally posted. As stated you have WAY TOO MANY injury concerns if you're keeping James, Taylor and Davis while giving up Dillon, Pittman and McAllister. Rework it so you keep at least Dillon, who while inconsistent has managed to stay healthy and one of the other two. Personally I'd dangle James and another of the RBs (Pittman, McAllister, Jones or Davis) hoping that he'll be convinced of James' full recovery (I'm not) which would still allow him a large piece of Indy's fantasy pie (which I think is going to shrink at least a little this year with Dungy).