In my keeper league (17 players, 6 keepers, starting 9 each week), 1 pt for 25 yards rushing/ receiving. Tds = 6.

I received the following offer:
I send Addai and a 5th round pick next year.
I get back Edgerrin James and Randy Moss.

Considering my roster
QB's: P. Manning, Warner
RB's: Addai, Fargas, T. Henry, Jordan, Lewis
WR's: Branch, Colston, Curry, Gonzalez, Gonzalez (Yep, got both of them), Harrison
K: J. Brown
D/ST: Dallas & Tennessee

Would you take the above deal? Frankly, I'm leaning strongly toward "No" because Addai has become a #1 stud RB. Would be nice to get Moss, but is a number 1 WR worth a #1 RB. Plus the draft choice, which I think I should be getting instead of giving away. Also the guys has pi$$ed me off so bad I don't feel like dealing with him.

What do you guys think?

You're correct in saying no on this one. Edge and Moss are getting up there in age and mileage. As well as Moss is playing, it only takes one tweak of the hammy that slowed him for three years, and he's worthless again. Addai is your future.