I have to pick between priest holmes and ladainian tomlinson. i'm in an 8 man 1 keeper league. i pick 6th in the draft and we score 1pt for every 10 yard rush/receive 6pt for every td.I feel tomlinson will only improve with boston opening things up but after last year a healthy holmes has to be #1 who would you keep and why?

You really can't go wrong either way. You can ask 100 people and 50 will say PH and 50 will say LT. I have Holmes rated higher than LT but both as tier 1 backs.

Both are studs. But LT is both younger and less of an "injury risk". Starting to hear good about Holmes just I would still take LT.

LT is the pick.

I would also keep LT. But it would be very tragic to have to throw Holmes back into the pool. Can you trade him for a draft pick? There has got to be a team that would rather have Priest than anyone they currently have.

Keep L.T.

The safe bet is LT, but if Holmes is 100% and plays 16 games he'll blow away the entire league again.

If you're feeling lucky go with Holmes. But your probably better off with LT as he should finish anywhere from 1-3

One more vote for LT because he's the safer (and younger) pick, although I agree I'd be thrilled with either.

i am as big a Holmes backer as there can b but i would go LT as well... u might b able to get Holmes back at the 6th pick depending on how people feel about him... LT is the best/safest back in the league expecially in a recpetion league